When a Friend is Diagnosed with Cancer, Say Something. (Just Don’t Say What I Said.)

What to say when a loved one has cancer, from someone who once said the wrong thing.

F​​ew things are harder than learning that someone we love has cancer. I’ve survived breast cancer myself and lost relatives to four other cancers, so friends often call me in a panic after someone they love is diagnosed, wanting to know what to say and do.

Our instinct is to jump in and problem-solve. We ask technical questions: Where is it? What stage? Could it be terminal? Do they have a good doctor? Maybe the worst well-meaning instinct is to question the treatment itself. Wouldn’t it be worth going somewhere else?

It’s funny that people ask me. I did not handle things well when my dear friend Susie Rinehart was diagnosed.

Susie and I have been friends for 30 years. Before she found out that she had a big brainstem tumor, we’d been talking on the phone about her desire to write a book. I don’t think it’s an exaggeration to say that in the months before her diagnosis, we’d clocked a dozen or more hours gabbing like middle schoolers in the 1980s (that is, endlessly on the phone, she in Colorado and I in California). I was trying to help her work out the particulars of her novel. Or fictionalized memoir. Or maybe it was meant to be a series of letters to her daughter. Or a self-help book for young women in their 20s.

Suffice it to say, we didn’t know what form the book would take. But we did know that Susie had an important book in her.

When she found out that she had a tumor wrapped around her brainstem—one that might not be operable and could possibly maim or kill her in as little as three months—she called me. When I didn’t pick up, she left me a message explaining that they’d finally figured out why she’d been having such severe headaches for the past couple of years: It was a massive, tentacled tumor. They were interviewing surgeons. A neurosurgeon friend was helping Susie find the best of the best. There was a long road ahead.

I was not as stunned or worried as you’d think I’d be upon learning that one of my dearest friends had a serious illness. Besides the book, we’d been talking a lot about her headaches. Two mysteries had been solved!

So instead of thinking through how one might appropriately respond to such news, I immediately called her back and left a long message:

Wow. I’m so sorry to hear that you have a tumor in your neck, but I’m so happy they’ve figured out what’s been causing your headaches! That’s so great. And I’m glad you are taking the time to find the best surgeon ever. Please let me know if there is anything I can do to help. And, also, not to be Pollyannaish about the ordeal that is surely ahead, but SUSIE! THIS IS YOUR BOOK!! You are going to write a memoir about this experience!!

My husband overheard me leave that message. After I told him what was going on, he said something like: “She just told you that she has brain cancer, and you told her, ‘Congratulations! This is going to make for a great book!’ Call her back right now. Maybe you can stop her from listening to that message.”

In my next message, I said little more than, “I am such a dumbass.”

Coincidentally, a few months later, I was having lunch with Kelsey Crowe, who was just launching her very helpful and funny book, There is No Good Card for This: What to Say and Do When Life is Scary, Awful, and Unfair to People You Love.

Kelsey confirmed that I had not responded at all appropriately to Susie’s diagnosis. She gave me a few pointers for the next time something awful happens to someone I love. Here are a few things I’ve learned from Susie, Kelsey, and my own experience with cancer:

1. Say something

While Kelsey admitted that what I chose to say to Susie was about the worst she’d ever heard, she was clear that saying something is always better than saying nothing. (Though you might need to apologize for being a dumbass, if you are like me.)

A lot of people don’t know what to say when something awful befalls a friend or colleague, and so they don’t say anything at all. It’s terrible for people going through something difficult to feel like others are avoiding them. Here are some things Kelsey suggests:

  • “I am sorry you are going through this.”
  • “I can’t imagine what you are going through. What’s that like for you?”
  • “I want you to know I am here for you if there is anything I can do.”
  • “You don’t look sick; how are you actually doing?”
  • “How are you feeling today?”
  • “I have seen you manage really tough things in the past, and I know that you can get through this.”

2. Offer support

Your friend’s diagnosis is an opportunity for you to reach out in whatever way you can. It’s a chance to connect, offer love, and show compassion. Your relationship will naturally deepen when you offer support, especially if you don’t expect anything in return.

Doing something, even something small, is better than “giving them space,” which may make them feel very alone at a time when they need their people. Delivering a casserole might seem a little retro, but keeping the kids fed and the family trains running is hard when you’re not feeling well (and nothing says “I love you” like lasagna).

If you don’t cook or can’t reliably deliver things like meals, don’t feel compelled to sign up for that type of support. Maybe send an inspirational poem if that’s more your thing. If you’re a long-distance friend, sending cards via snail mail is a great way to show you love them and are rooting for them in a way that doesn’t demand a response. Or, if you live nearby, perhaps you can run errands for your friend or be there to hold her hand during treatments. Do something that a) your friend needs and b) that you would actually look forward to doing. That’s the thing that will create the strongest connection between you two.

3. Hold space for the scary, awful unfairness of it all

Your loved one’s life may have just fallen apart. There’s probably zero chance that they’re not thinking about the fact that they might die. Those are some really hard thoughts to be alone with.

So even though our first impulse is often to cheer someone up, offer platitudes like “God never gives us something we can’t handle,” or find a silver lining, sometimes optimism can make a sick person feel more alone and afraid. We can be hopeful that treatments will work and that everything will be okay in the end—and at the same time we can acknowledge the scary, awful, unfair outcomes that are also a possibility. Specifically, we can hold a place for them to say the unimaginable:

  • “I might die.”
  • “My children might grow up without a mother.”
  • “Everything has fallen apart.”

Because Susie encouraged me to do this with another friend who had been diagnosed with testicular cancer, I started by telling him that I was there for him if he wanted to talk about all the dark things that were going through his head. I said, “I don’t believe you are going to jinx yourself if we talk about what you are most afraid of. Sometimes it can help to speak out loud about the worst-case scenarios.” Those conversations were brief—like a door we barely opened and flinched as we peeked through—but they were among the most moving and heartfelt I’ve ever had with anyone in my life.

Be the person who can see that their whole life may have been dumped upside down, that they’ve already lost a lot, and that they are likely having some big, scary feelings. Let them feel that you are with them as they face their fear and grief.

Fortunately, Susie forgave me for my initial response to her diagnosis, because that’s the kind of friend she is. She also wrote an AMAZING book about her experience. It’s called Fierce Joy: Choosing Brave over Perfect to Find My True Voice. I hope you’ll read it.

Every Thursday, I post a research-based essay about how to live well in body, brain, and spirit. No supplement links, no 2+ hour podcast, and no promise that you’ll make it to 120. If that’s the kind of well-being you’re after, subscribe.

Related Posts

  • Grow, Love

    7 Ways to Help Someone Do a Hard Thing

  • Grow, Love

    Change is Easier When It’s Shared

  • Love

    The Surprising Benefits of Generosity

  • Love

    Happiness Tip: Smile at the Barista